22 Jul 2006
Ethnic Relations, a new subject in universities, is seen by many as something that cannot be taught in the classroom as integration and understanding should come naturally. ANIS IBRAHIM spent an afternoon sitting through one of the lessons at Universiti Putra Malaysia to find out if it could.
HOW does one teach a subject like "Ethnic Relations"? How does one teach a group of people, first, that they should be kind to others no matter the ethnicity of the "other" and, second, how and why they should do so?
In an attempt to find answers to those questions, I was assigned to sit in at an Ethnic Relations lecture at Universiti Putra Malaysia.
I, for one, was curious to know what materials would be relied on. I was also prepared to sneak into the lecture hall and plead ignorance to university regulations if necessary, but the entire process turned out to be rather open and transparent.
The lecturer, Dr Amini Amir Abdullah, was at first wary of letting a journalist in, but finally allowed me to attend his lecture.
There were about 70 students in the class that day. Although the group was mixed with first-year students of different ethnic backgrounds, there was a marked Malay majority. The rest of the seats were taken up by Chinese and Indian students.
I also noticed that there were no distinct "racial seating boundaries", which I thought was rather apt for the nature of the subject.
Amini went through the history of the various ethnic groups in Malaysia, including why and when the second largest group — the Chinese and the Indians — had come here.
He also mentioned the Malacca Sultanate, which saw dozens of nationalities mingling with each other.
"Racial integration during that time, however, was superficial, as it was merely to carry on trade and to ease communication.
"Our present integration is at a much deeper level. There is a purpose to our solidarity, as all of us have made Malaysia our country," he said.
For what some would describe as a dry subject, the students appeared to be paying attention and taking notes, although there was the occasional whisper or giggle from the back rows.
Only one question was raised, however, throughout the two-hour lecture.
"Would the presence of foreign nationals jeopardise our racial integration?" asked a Malay student.
Amini said that would not be possible as "foreign nationals add to the flavour of the country and may help the country move along if they also provide us with labour. If our ties are strong enough, foreigners won’t affect our relations".
A student I spoke to later said: "We already know how important it is to be respectful of each other. I’m only in this class because I have to attend it."
I left UPM that day with mixed feelings.
Although I felt the purpose of the classes was a good idea (anything that can help to strengthen ties in a multi-racial country can’t be a bad thing), I couldn’t decide whether the classes would be enough to achieve what they were supposed to.
Teachers can teach, but students must actually learn what is taught.